Pricing & Flavors

Find Your Perfect Cookie Tier 🍪

At All Good Things Cookies, from simple and sweet to elegant and extravagant—we’ve got a cookie tier to fit your moment and your budget! Whether you're ordering for a corporate event, a baby shower, or a once-in-a-lifetime celebration, you'll find a custom cookie option that’s just right.

Classic

Starting at $40/dozen

Simple, sweet, and budget-friendly! Our Classic set is perfect for those wanting beautiful custom cookies - without the extra frills. Ideal for large orders, corporate events, or any time you want something custom but simple.

✔ Up to 3 designs per dozen
✔ Basic detailing (lines, dots, minimal texture)
✔ 2–3 icing colors
✔ No extras (metallics, florals, or intricate piping) - just clean, classic cookies!
📌 Great for bulk orders & budget-conscious customers!

Fancy

Starting at $50/dozen

The Fancy set is a balanced mix of simple cookies with a few more intricate designs, creating a cohesive and elevated look that works beautifully for weddings, showers, birthdays, and special gifts.

✔ Up to 4 unique designs per dozen
✔ A mix of simple and more detailed cookies
✔ Up to 4 icing colors
✔ Light florals and minimal metallic accents

The perfect balance of creativity and simplicity.

Extravagant

Starting at $65/dozen

Your most detailed, show-stopping set,
The Extravagant set is designed to impress, featuring primarily intricate designs with rich detail, texture, and custom elements throughout the set. These cookies are made to stand out and serve as the focal point of any celebration.

✔ 4–6 unique designs per dozen
✔ Primarily detailed cookies with a few simpler designs for balance
✔ Advanced detailing with layered dimension
✔ Full color palette
✔ Florals, metallics, and hand-painted accents

Perfect for luxury events, bold themes, and statement-making sets.

👉 Get Started – Request a Quote

Cookie Quality + Flavor Promise

Crafted with care. Baked with purpose. Sweetened with love.

Details & Ingredients

Our cookies are known for their intricate detail, soft bite, and unforgettable flavor. Each one is hand-crafted, rolled, and cut to 5/16" thick—creating a soft, buttery texture that melts in your mouth. Most cookies range from 3" to 4.5" in diameter.

We use only premium ingredients: real butter, unbleached flour, and pure emulsion—for cookies as beautiful as they are delicious.

Flavor Options

We offer a variety of crowd-pleasing signature flavors:

Signature – A buttery vanilla-almond blend with a hint of lemon and orange. Tastes like an old-fashioned pound cake.
Traditional – Classic butter vanilla.
Orange Creamsicle – Orange and vanilla with vanilla chips.
Chocolate – Rich and fudgy, like a brownie.
Churro – Warm cinnamon-sugar flavor with a hint of vanilla.
Lemon – Bright, tangy lemon with the perfect touch of sweetness.

Sweet Truth: “Taste and see that the Lord is good; blessed is the one who takes refuge in Him.” – Psalm 34:8

🍪Every cookie is made with love, prayer, and ingredients you can be proud to share.

Customization Details

Decorated cookies are fully customizable to suit your event, vision, and budget—there’s no “cookie cutter” approach here! You can mix and match from our Classic, Fancy, and Extravagant tiers to build the perfect set.

Minimum order: 1 dozen
Additional cookies: May be added in half-dozen increments
Pricing: Based on design complexity (see tiers above)
Packaging: All cookies are individually heat-sealed for freshness and boxed for presentation

Sweet Truth: You were made to stand out—not fit in a mold. 🍪 So are our cookies.

SHIPPING

Need them shipped? We'll pack them with care - or prep them for you to send!

📦 In-State Shipping (Alabama):
– $10 packaging fee per dozen (includes individually sealing, boxing, and delivering to the post office)
– Actual USPS shipping cost (usually around $11/dozen) is added to this price

📬 Out-of-State Shipping:
– $10 packaging fee per dozen
– You or someone local will need to handle mailing; unfortunately, we cannot ship out of state on your behalf

We take extra care to ensure your cookies arrive safely!
Scroll through to see how we wrap, cushion, and tape each order to keep your cookies safe and snuggly during transit. 💝